Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
HSE CHIEF EXECUTIVE Anne O’Connor has told an Oireachtas committee that she is “concerned” about the minutes of a meeting held between CUH CEO Jennifer Kearney and HSE regional executive officer (REO) Andy Phillips.
Tensions between the HSE and CUH CEO Jennifer Kearney have emerged in recent months after safety concerns at the hospital were raised publicly in August when a letter from Kearney to senior HSE officials made its way to the media.
Following the release of that letter, a meeting held between Kearney and Phillips, and other senior staff at Cork University Hospital, was held, which was later revealed to be recorded.
It was reported that Phillips told Kearney that he had been “instructed by the Taoiseach’s office and the Minister for Health’s office to have some very specific conversations with you”.
In the Dáil during Leaders’ Questions, the Taoiseach denied this was the case, and said that “false assertions” were made about his office. The Irish Times published the recording of the meeting on its website earlier this month.
The audio recording subsequently clarified that the Taoiseach’s office had been referenced in the meeting. Phillips also made reference to performance reviews being carried out on Kearney and hospital management.
Asked about the meeting today at the Oireachtas Health Committee, O’Connor said that she has seen the minutes of the meeting, adding “I am concerned”.
She told the committee she had not heard the recording of the meeting, although it was pointed out to her that it has been published online.
Asked how she has dealt with the matter, O’Connor said she has met and spoken to Phillips, and he had “apologised for what he said”. She said she expressed concern about his comments to him during that meeting.
O’Connor said Phillips explained that the comments were made in the heat of the moment during his meeting with Kearney.
Labour TD Eoghan Kenny asked the HSE boss if she thought Phillips’ job was tenable.
O’Connor responded by saying there was a job of work to be done by the REO, but she said “I can’t get into that,” when asked about the person in the job.
“The Taoiseach’s office should never be brought into disrepute by any civil servant, but that’s exactly what was done by the REO of HSE southwest, and you took to the radio to say he said this out of frustration … I do not believe his position is tenable,” said Kenny.
Aside from questions about the secret recording, O’Connor was also criticised by TDs for saying CUH was “conducting its management business via the media with extraordinary regularity”.
O’Connor made the remarks in her opening statement submitted to the committee. She said:
“As a hospital, CUH is not unique in facing huge service pressures. But it is unique in that it appears to be conducting its management business via the media with extraordinary regularity.”
Labour TD Marie Sherlock said, as a result of the remarks, “the message is now going out” from the HSE that doctors and nurses cannot speak up and advocate for their patients, adding:
I think that’s very dangerous.
She said it was really regrettable that there was an “attempt to sow division”.
The HSE boss also confirmed to the committee that she has not spoken with Kearney.
Sherlock said it is remarkable and outrageous that the HSE boss had not yet had a conversation with the CEO of CUH given the level of controversy.
Sinn Féin’s David Cullinane said:
“I think people can see with their own eyes, chair what’s happening… And I have to say, I do find it extraordinary that given everything that’s happened, that you haven’t even had a conversation with the CEO.”
He asked O’Connor if she believes staff have an obligation to speak out if they feel there are patient safety issues and whether she has an objection to hospital management speaking out publicly.
“I don’t have an objection to people speaking at all about patient safety or risk. What I am concerned about is that there are organisational and governance processes there,” she said.
O’Connor’s opening statement stated that the increase in staffing this year at CUH has been bigger than the combined increase in Beaumont, St James and Tallaght University hospitals.
“CUH and many other hospitals have seen a significant increase in its emergency presentation in recent times. However, all hospitals have responsibility to manage their services and provide reassurance to patients while ensuring that the public money provided to them is managed in the most effective way possible for their communities,” O’Connor told TDs and senators.
On the working environment at the hospital, O’Connor said it must be changed from what has been “created recently” so that staff can work with the HSE “respectfully and professionally”.
At the weekend, in an interview on RTÉ Radio 1, O’Connor downplayed staffing and safety concerns at CUH but did acknowledge that staff at the hospital were not working together effectively.
She also suggested that a meeting between senior HSE and hospital staff was “illegally recorded” and said CUH staff were “fearful” of going to meetings and being recorded without their knowledge.
Taoiseach Micheál Martin has criticised the recording of the meeting in question, telling reporters on Monday that he was “deeply concerned” by the issue.
He said issues that exist in relation to staffing and patient safety at the hospital will not be solved by “megaphone engagement”.
have your say